16S reanalysis · Ng et al. 2019 humanised mice

Primary result: distance from baseline after ciprofloxacin

Bray–Curtis distance between each mouse’s window samples (days 8–12) and its own day-0 sample, averaged within mouse and then within cage. The analysis plan was frozen before any diet comparison.

−0.145Low-MAC − standard contrast (cage-equal)
2 of 2low-MAC cages below all three standard-diet cages
17 / 5eligible mice / cages
Overlapindividual mice overlap between diets

Figure 1

The cage pattern was stable across the tested Bray–Curtis versions but depended on the distance metric.

Panel A: Bray-Curtis distance from day 0 for each mouse, with cage means and diet means; low-MAC (PD) cages lie below standard-diet (STD) cages while individual mice overlap. Panel B: the PD minus STD contrast for each distance-from-baseline analysis as a percentage of the STD mean.

A: Bray–Curtis distance from each mouse’s own day-0 sample, mean of days 8–12. Points are mice, bars are cage means, dashed lines are the cage-equal diet means. B: the PD − STD contrast in every distance-from-baseline analysis, as % of the STD mean (the metrics have different scales); the contrast in the original units is printed on the right. Percentages express each contrast relative to its own STD mean; they do not represent percentage recovery. 218/166 = forward/reverse read truncation lengths (sensitivity setting; primary 200/150). PD = low-MAC diet (the paper’s MD arm); STD = standard diet.

Cage values

DietCageMiceCage mean
StandardH_c140.897
StandardH_c240.812
StandardH_c320.882
Low-MACH_c440.712
Low-MACH_c530.724

Diet means: standard 0.864, low-MAC 0.718 (Δ = −0.145).

How to read this