The same checksummed per-sample reads were processed by nf-core/ampliseq 3.1.0 with DADA2 settings matched to QIIME 2, and the frozen analysis was rerun. The decision rule was tagged before the second workflow ran.
Cage values of the frozen primary measure in the two workflows.
Each point is one cage: the cage mean of the Bray–Curtis distance between each mouse’s days 8–12 samples and its own day-0 sample, computed from QIIME 2 (horizontal) and nf-core/ampliseq (vertical). STD = standard diet; PD = low-MAC diet (the paper’s MD arm). The dashed line marks equal values. The diet contrast differed by 0.0001 between workflows (−0.1454 against −0.1453), against a prespecified tolerance of 0.02, and the cage pattern was the same.
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Read retention | Final read count per sample, nf-core/ampliseq ÷ QIIME 2: median 1.000 (range 0.983–1.001) |
| ASVs | 788 shared, carrying 99.99% of QIIME 2 reads and 100.00% of ampliseq reads (rounded); the rest are rare |
| Same sample, two workflows | Bray–Curtis median 0.0000, maximum 0.017 (two truncation settings within QIIME 2: median 0.024) |
| Frozen contrast | −0.1453 against −0.1454: same direction; difference 0.0001 against a tolerance of 0.02 |
Agreement shows reproducibility under matched processing, not robustness to analysis choices; robustness was assessed separately with sensitivity analyses.